Risky Business by KCIC

KCIC.com
  • HOME
  • CLAIMS ADMIN
  • DISPUTE RESOLUTION
  • INSURANCE & RISK
  • TECH
  • CULTURE

Game-Winning Strategies When Reaching Excess Layer of Coverage

March 13, 2014 By Nancy Gutzler Leave a Comment

Page 1Reaching the excess layer of coverage can pose many obstacles for policyholders. For that reason, a roundtable luncheon was devoted to the topic during the American Bar Association’s Annual Insurance Coverage Litigation Conference in Tucson.

I was happy to be part of that lively discussion, which for its title took a cue from a popular childhood game: “Chutes and Ladders: Hurdles and Rewards of Reaching the Excess Layer of Coverage.”

I was joined by Anna Engh of Covington & Burling and Tony Jones of Troutman Sanders. Our luncheon talk focused on:

Implications of Qualcomm and Zeig Caselaw – These cases address whether a policyholder can settle with a primary insurer for less than policy limits without jeopardizing excess coverage. Since specific language in an excess policy is critical, I shared how KCIC’s Ligado Platform allows policyholders to effectively store, summarize, and manage this type of data when settling or litigating insurance coverage. We also discussed ways to avoid the pitfalls associated with Qualcomm policy language: reading and knowing your excess policy language before reaching a settlement with a primary insurer, or settling with excess insurers before the primary.

Horizontal and Vertical Exhaustion of the Primary Layer – Also touched on were ways insurers and policyholders might account for settlement credits in an “all-sums” ruling. Outcomes could vary significantly with a non-settled insurer when accounting for settlement credits based on the amount received from the settled insurer versus the amount of limits settled with the insurer. We also discussed a case currently pending before the Ohio Supreme Court. It surrounds vertical spiking by a policyholder in an “all-sums” jurisdiction where the policyholder has settled with its primary insurers on a horizontal pro-rata basis.

Burden of Proving the Underlying Exhaustion – We concluded with a discussion around the task of proving that underlying coverage is exhausted. While primary insurers may take the lead in handling underlying claims, the record keeping often does not meet an excess insurer’s requirements. We talked about how to combine different sources (loss runs, underlying claims files, internal policyholder spreadsheets, or summary information) to form a more complete picture. We also debated who ultimately bears the burden of proving that the primary is truly exhausted.

What Do You Think?

Do you have thoughts, tips or experiences to share on reaching the excess layer of coverage? I welcome your comments.

Filed Under: Insurance & Risk, Technology Tagged With: American Bar Association, Conferences, Corporate Insurance, Covington & Burling, Excess Layer of Coverage, Insurance & Risk, Ligado, Qualcomm, Risk Management, Risk Management Technology, Underlying Exhaustion

Nancy Gutzler

About Nancy Gutzler

Nancy Gutzler has over 25 years of experience providing financial and litigation support and expert testimony services to clients. She has assisted clients with analysis of claims data, sampling of claims populations, allocation of claims costs to insurance coverage, and development of claims processing procedures and systems. Ms. Gutzler has particular expertise in claims analysis and administration of many types of mass tort claims, especially those related to asbestos personal injury, and has consulted with clients on various issues related to the analysis of large volumes of claims.

Meet the Contributors

Jonathan TerrellJonathan Terrell
Dan SnyderDan Snyder
Nick SochurekNick Sochurek
Megan ShockleyMegan Shockley
Carrie ScottCarrie Scott
Michelle PotterMichelle Potter
Andrew PetryszakAndrew Petryszak
Chris MonahanChris Monahan
Elizabeth HankeElizabeth Hanke
Nancy GutzlerNancy Gutzler
Chris CrookChris Crook

ARCHIVES

QUICK LINKS

CLAIMS ADMIN
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
INSURANCE & RISK
TECHNOLOGY
CULTURE
KCIC.COM
LinkedIn Icon Twitter Icon

Tag Cloud

insurance Risk Asbestos asbestos litigation claims administration Risk Management Consulting Litigation Claims Technology Berkshire Hathaway claims management Culture product liability KCIC KCIC Cares mesothelioma Insurance Coverage Corporate Insurance company culture data KCIC Culture

CONTACT

KCIC
733 10th Street, NW
Suite 3001
Washington, DC 20001

P: 202-772-2300
F: 202-772-2333
E: contact@kcic.com

Copyright © 2018 | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Risky Business - KCIC.com